Coffey & Company, Inc. is dedicated and passionate about increasing the success, security and well being of clients, carriers, colleagues and community. It is our mission to utilize the resources of our firm to be "the best by any measure" which means, always getting better while striving to realize our potential in the services we provide. Coffey & Company is an organization built upon three main beliefs — integrity, professionalism and competence.

Business Insurance

From the home-based entrepreneur to the international corporation, every business has it's own risks, concerns, and priorities. Coffey & Company builds a customized program for each client founded on personal services, experience, and the highest quality coverages from top carriers. With seventeen markets to choose from, you can be confident that we will provide you the best program for your operation.

Learn More

Employee Benefits

Successful companies see their benefit program as an integral piece of the compensation package because they recognize value in its ability to help attract and retain quality employees.  In today’s highly competitive markets, a company’s ability to differentiate itself may be the difference between having a best and brightest minds working for you or your competition. 

Learn More

Personal Insurance

The difference Coffey & Company brings to insuring your personal assets lies in our years of experience and access to competitive and comprehensive programs. Many of our clients have gone out of their way to express satisfaction with our rapid service at the time of a claim and our dedication to going the extra mile to protect our clients. In a time of 800 numbers and phone mail, let us exceed your expectations.

Learn More

Financial Services

Our Financial Services Division developed out of a need of our corporate clients to protect their income and families against the unexpected. With the abundance of agents touting “expertise” in the field of financial services that had saturated the market, these business-owners and entrepreneurs were looking to build a relationship with someone they had experience working with.

Learn More

Exciting News from Coffey & Company!

By Wayne Coffey 1| December 3, 2018

As you may be aware, Coffey & Company and First National Insurance Agency will soon combine operations to create one of the largest, independent insurance agencies in the region. First National Insurance Agency is an affiliate of First National Bank of Pennsylvania, a diversified national bank operating approximately 400 banking locations across Pennsylvania, Maryland, Ohio, West Virginia, North Carolina and Read More

MLR Rebates

By Brad Leddon 1| September 21, 2018

It’s that time of the year again, when you get your end of summer bonus from your insurance carrier! About time they started returning some of those premiums you’ve been paying, right? I’m referring to the Medical Loss Ratio (MLR) rebate checks. These are the cryptic payments that employers receive, generally with very little explanation and virtually no breakdown or Read More

Our Partners

Coffey & Company is a proud member of Vistage, the top CEO development group in the world and a partner member in Accelerent, a leading business development program. Wayne Coffey is also the founder of the non-profit No More Stolen Childhoods, created to raise awareness of childhood sexual abuse.